New Grandparent’s Rights Rule in Wisconsin

This spring, in the highly anticipated case, Michels v. Lyons, the Wisconsin Supreme Court changed how the circuit court interprets the Wisconsin grandparent’s rights law. The Wisconsin grandparent’s rights law allows for the circuit court to award visitation to grandparents under certain conditions. This law has been somewhat controversial as the courts must balance the interests of parent’s deemed to be fit making decisions for their children, and the importance of the relationship between grandparents and children. This law applies to paternity and divorce cases where the parents are not married.

In the Michels v. Lyons case, the Wisconsin Supreme Court determined that the Grandparent’s Visitation Statute, Wis. Stat. 767.43, is constitutional which means that grandparents continue to have the right to ask the court to order visitation with their grandchildren. However, in order for the circuit court to award visitation to a grandparent, the grandparent must overcome the court’s presumption that the parent’s visitation decision is in the child’s best interest and prove, with clear and convincing evidence, that the parent’s decision regarding visitation with the grandparents was not in the child’s best interest.

In other words, it is the grandparent’s responsibility to prove to the court, at the highest level of proof required in a civil case, that the parent’s decision (usually to reduce or stop visitation between their child and the child’s grandparent) is not in the child’s best interest. The Court made it more difficult for the courts to substitute what their judgment, or a grandparent’s opinion, of what is in the child’s best interest for visitation for that of a fit parent’s judgment. This can be an uphill battle for a grandparent seeking court ordered visitation.

However, it does not mean that a grandparent cannot succeed in a motion to set grandparent visitation. There has always been an assumption that fit parent’s decisions as to visitation between a child and a grandparent is what is in the child’s best interest. The change is that in a motion for grandparent visitation it is the grandparent’s responsibility to prove that the parent’s decision is not in the child’s best interest. This is a more difficult thing to prove.

There are many fact scenarios where the Court could see that grandparents could be successful. For example, if the minor child has resided with the grandparent for a period of time, or provided care to the minor child on a consistent basis. If a parent decides to cut off all contact between a minor child and a grandparent, especially in such a situation where there is an established relationship in the examples above, it may be appropriate for the circuit court to order visitation in that situation. Grandparents visitation cases may be more common when a parent decides to reside with a grandparent to get back on their feet after the end of a relationship, or during and after a divorce. Depending upon several factors, it may be more likely to see the relationship between a grandparent and grandchild reach a level envisioned by the Court to meet the burden of proof necessary to award court ordered visitation.

This new standard in the grandparent visitation cases places a greater emphasis on fit parents’ decisions regarding visitation between a grandparent and their minor child. However, it still contemplates many situations where there should be visitation ordered by the circuit court when this parental decision can be proven by clear and convincing evidence to not be in the child’s best interest. The Court acknowledges the importance of preserving a relationship between a grandparent and a grandchild.  However, these relationships must be balanced with a fit parent’s decision. If you are involved in a situation regarding grandparent’s visitation, whether you are a grandparent, or a parent, call us at (414) 258-1644 to schedule a free initial consultation to discuss your case.

Wisconsin Supreme Court Resolves Issues Regarding Grandparents and Stepparents Rights

Grandparents And Granddaughter Walking On Winter BeachUntil recently, Wisconsin case law supported an interpretation of Wis. Stat. § 767.43(1) that required a grandparent, great-grandparent, or stepparent to prove “a parent-like relationship” with the child in order to secure visitation rights. However, the Supreme Court of Wisconsin’s ruling in the recently decided Meister* case made it clear that only a person other than a grandparent, or stepparent filing a motion for visitation must prove “a parent-like relationship.”

The Court, through this decision, eliminated an additional and unintended barrier for grandparents and stepparents who are seeking visitation rights. This change in the interpretation of the law will open the door to more grandparents, great-grandparents and stepparents who wish to seek visitation rights. Regardless of this barrier being eliminated, it does not guarantee that the grandparents or stepparents will prevail. The Court must “consider the constitutional rights of the parents” and “decide, in its sound discretion, whether the facts and circumstances of the case warrant granting, modifying, or denying a visitation petition in the best interest of the child.”

It is important to note that the above applies to children born to married parents. For children of unmarried (and subsequently never married) parents, the visitation statute still requires that a grandparent or stepparent show they have “maintained a relationship with the child or have attempted to maintain a relationship with the child but have been prevented from doing so by a parent who has legal custody of the child.” Again, however, this type of relationship does not have to be “parent-like” in nature.

If you are a grandparent, great-grandparent or stepparent seeking visitation rights of a child, it is important that you have an attorney navigate you through this evolving area of the law. If you wish to speak with an attorney at our office, please call 414-258-1644 for a free ½ hour office consultation.
* In re the Marriage of Meister, Nancy and Jay. 2016 WI 22.

Grandparent Visitation in Wisconsin

Are you a grandparent who hasn’t been able to see your grandchildren for some reason? Do you have any “rights” to seek visitation from the court?

In Wisconsin, the courts strongly protect the rights of parents to raise their children as they see fit, without outside interference. The statutes do permit grandparents, or those who have had a “parent-like” relationship with the child, to petition the court for visitation. This is only true, however, if there is an action affecting the family (divorce, legal separation, paternity) pending.

If there is no action pending and the parents are still married, grandparents are not allowed to petition the court for visitation. Unless the parents are unfit or incompetent, there is no recourse for grandparents who want to see their grandchildren. In those instances, your best course of action as a grandparent is to repair or attempt to repair the circumstances which led to the breakdown in your relationship with your child or grandchild in the first place.

This protection of parental rights carries through to an action for divorce or legal separation where the standard for grandparent visitation is a bit different than a situation where the parents where never married. The statute simply states that visitation can be granted if it is in the best interests of the child. However, there is no definition or qualifying standards to determine what that means. This gives the court very broad discretion in those instances. The US Supreme Court has ruled, however, that courts must apply a presumption that a fit parent’s decision regarding non-parental visitation is in the best interest of the child. The Wisconsin courts have upheld this presumption. What that means is that if both parents (married or formerly married) have refused to allow grandparent visitation, it is going to be difficult to ask the court to interfere with that decision.

In a divorce, the courts usually find that grandparents should see the children during their own child’s placement time. Parents have little enough time with their children when their time is already divided between two people. The courts are going to be very reluctant to divide the time three ways. If the relationship between the parent and the grandparent is broken down to the point where the parent will not allow the grandparents to see the child on his or her own time, the court is going to be reluctant to interfere with that decision based on the above presumption.

However, if a parent is not seeing the child(ren) for some reason, which does not afford the grandparents the opportunity to see their grandchildren, then the court is likely to order some visitation to preserve the child’s relationship with their grandparents.

In a paternity case (where the parents were never married), the courts are much more likely to grant a grandparent visitation. The statute sets forth a different standard. Best interests apply but the statute also allows visitation more broadly in situations where grandparents have had a relationship in the past or have attempted to maintain a relationship in the past but now are prevented from doing so by the parent with legal custody. The court must find, however, the grandparents will not interfere with the custodial decisions of the parent. In the case of the benevolent grandparents who only want to see their grandchildren, this virtually guarantees some kind of visitation.

The difficulty comes in when you have interfering grandparents or grandparents who have attempted to control or take over parental decisions. In those instances, the court may be reluctant to give grandparents the opportunity to interfere or damage the parental relationship with the child which it protects above all else.

If you are a grandparent seeking visitation with your grandchild or grandchildren, make sure that you do not attempt to interfere with the relationship between parent and child. Keep in mind that you do not have any “rights” over your grandchildren except to have a relationship with them. Your actions are going to be scrutinized by the court to determine whether visitation with you is in the best interest of the child(ren). If you cause problems or take actions which can be interpreted to be contrary to parental decisions, you very well may be giving the court just cause to deny visitation. You should consult with an experienced family law attorney to determine if you have a basis to petition the court for visitation and what actions you should take which would lead to the best chance of success in your case.

If you have any questions about grandparent visitation and would like to meet with one of our lawyers for a free initial office consultation, please call us at 414-258-1644. You can also visit our website for more information.